Ear and hearing health system

A broad range of policies and programs provides ear and hearing services for First Nations people, with the provision of these services being complex and fragmented. This section describes the broad policy context. It also provides an overview of ear and hearing health services across the continuum of care from awareness, prevention, screening, diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation.

Broad policy context

The following initiatives form part of the broader policy context for ear and hearing health among First Nations people:

  • the National Agreement on Closing the Gap was developed in partnership between Australian governments and the Coalition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peak Organisations. It has been built around four Priority Reforms which will change the way governments work with First Nations people and communities and includes 17 outcome areas over the life course. One outcome area, closely related to ear and hearing health, is to ensure that ‘Children thrive in their early years’ 
  • the Roadmap for Hearing Health – which identifies priority areas and actions to improve hearing health and its impacts for First Nations people
  • the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Ear and Hearing Health Partnership Committee (a partnership between the Australian Government, states and territories and First Nations representatives in the hearing health sector) – which aims to transition ear health promotion, community engagement functions and training and workforce development coordination to community-controlled organisations. The committee has provided input to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Ear and Hearing Health National Strategy, led by the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO).

Policies and programs

A broad range of policies and programs provides ear and hearing services for First Nations people, with the provision of these services being complex and fragmented. A preliminary mapping of the policy and program landscape is provided below and in Table 3. This policy and program landscape includes programs and services for all Australians, not just those specifically for First Nations people. The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) will continue to work with the Ear and Hearing Advisory Group to develop a more comprehensive mapping of ear and hearing health policies and programs for First Nations people in Australia.

First Nations ear or hearing related services, policies and programs in Australia

Note: These are a selection of current First Nations ear or hearing related services, policies and programs in Australia; it is not a comprehensive overview of all services, policies, programs and organisations providing services.

National, state and territory governments share funding, operational and management responsibilities. Service provision – through private hospitals, medical practices, audiology services and rehabilitation services – is also spread across the private, for profit, and non‑profit sectors. As a result:

  • the system (like the whole health system) is complex for consumers to access and navigate
  • providers face challenges in resourcing, delivering and reporting on services
  • it is difficult to maintain ongoing data collections and monitor change over time
  • better data are needed to evaluate programs and inform decisions.

The Universal Neonatal Hearing Screening Program provides a model for integrated ear and hearing services as different service components are interconnected from the outset.

While not comprehensive, Table INTRODUCTION 2 highlights some of the ear and hearing health programs that exist around the country as well as their key sources of funding. This table does not include the many unnamed programs that provide important services to communities.

Table INTRODUCTION 2: First Nations ear or hearing related services, policies and programs in Australia

*If met additional eligibility criteria.

Notes:

  1. AG = Australian Government; ECE = early childhood educators; S/T = state/territory; PHC=Primary health care nurse.
  2. PLUM and HATS are not programs but tools that workers can use.
  3. ASOHNS = Australian Society of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery

Service providers, services and settings 

The diversity of ear and hearing health services, providers and settings and the connections between them illustrate the complexity of the ear and hearing health system. These are summarised in Table INTRODUCTION 3. 

Providers

Ear and hearing health-care services are provided by various health-care professionals. These include Aboriginal Health Workers, general practitioners (GPs) and nurses (including audiometry nurses and maternal and child health nurses). Health services are also provided by First Nations health practitioners, community hearing health workers, ear health workers and coordinators, audiologists, audiometrists, clinical nurse specialists, ENT specialists, child ear and hearing health coordinators, occupational therapists, speech pathologists, paediatricians, other health practitioners, allied health workers and nurses. At any point along the continuum of care, a number of providers may need to work together as a team to support ear and hearing health outcomes. More complex health issues and related impacts – such as speech, language and behavioural development – are likely to require a larger and more diverse team of health professionals.

Ear health workers and coordinators work with communities and health-care providers to build skills and knowledge that help prevent and treat ear disease and hearing loss and identify pathways to ear and hearing health services. Other professionals, including support workers, interpreters and teachers, provide vital diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation support for people with an ear disease or hearing loss.

Families, workplaces, and professionals not traditionally considered part of the health-care system – such as teachers, early childhood education and care professionals, teachers of the deaf, and support workers – also help to prevent, identify and manage ear and hearing problems, and to provide support and rehabilitation services.

Services

There are many challenges in identifying ear and hearing problems using screening and diagnostic tests, and a number of services may be involved in this process. Continuity of care is a particular challenge in identifying and managing ear and hearing health problems as conditions such as chronic and recurring middle ear infections require multiple screenings at the right times by the same provider or by a team of providers.

Once diagnosed, ear disease and conductive hearing loss can be managed or treated in various ways. ‘Watchful waiting’, which means monitoring a child’s hearing and ear examinations over time, is often used in preference to medical or surgical interventions when the hearing loss is minimal and there is access to a clinic to enable regular reviews. This model works well in the team environment where the behavioural, speech and language implications of hearing loss can be monitored in addition to the condition of the ear. Ear disease and conductive hearing loss can also be treated with medical and surgical interventions. Chronic or recurrent ear infections can be treated with antibiotics. Other procedures include cleaning ears and removing wax, incising the eardrum to remove fluid, inserting grommets (drainage tubes), and repairing perforations to the eardrum. Sensorineural hearing loss and other hearing problems such as tinnitus cannot usually be treated or reversed.

The impact of both temporary and permanent ear and hearing problems can be mitigated through rehabilitation. Rehabilitation reduces the impact of ear disease and hearing loss and helps to ensure ongoing access to communication through interventions such as:

  • hearing aids or cochlear implants
  • speech and/or occupational therapy
  • counselling
  • teaching and/or school assistance.

For example, the impacts of conductive or temporary hearing loss on speech and language development can be mitigated with the use of hearing aids and other rehabilitation services.

Settings

Most people enter the ear and hearing health system through primary health-care services delivered in settings such as Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services, general practices, community health centres and allied health practices. Alternatively, people may attend screening programs, visit hospital emergency departments or present at an audiology clinic or hearing aid provider.

Accessibility and availability of culturally safe ear and hearing health specialist services are key to First Nations people receiving timely diagnosis and treatment.

Table INTRODUCTION 3: Overview of ear and hearing health services
 ServicesProvidersSettingsAccess
Prevention
  • Education
  • Awareness raising
  • Families and carers
  • First Nations Health Workers 
  • Early childhood educators
  • Employers
  • Households
  • Communities and community events
  • Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services
  • Other Indigenous-specific primary health-care services
  • Community clinics and health centres
  • Schools and early childhood education and care services
  • Workplaces
No referral required
ScreeningEar examinations
Audiometric assessments (which may require complementary assessments, including hearing, tympanometry and/or pneumatic otoscopy)
  • First Nations Health Workers
  • General Practitioners (GP)
  • Nurses
  • Audiologists
  • Audiometrists
  • Audiometry Nurses
  • Ear Health Coordinators
  • Paediatricians
  • Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services
  • Other Indigenous-specific primary health-care services
  • Community clinics and health centres
  • Private practices and clinics
  • Hospitals
  • Schools and early childhood education and care services
No referral required
Diagnosis
  • History taking
  • Ear examinations
  • Audiometric assessments (which may require complementary assessments, including hearing, tympanometry and/or pneumatic otoscopy)
  • Balance assessments
  • Other scans, biopsies, cultures or tests
  • First Nations Health Workers 
  • GPs
  • Nurses
  • Audiologists
  • Audiometrists
  • Audiometry Nurses 
  • Ear Health Coordinators
  • Paediatricians
  • Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services
  • Other Indigenous-specific primary health-care services
  • Community clinics and health centres
  • Private practices and clinics
  • Hospitals
  • Outreach services
Referral required for some subsidised audiology and ENT services

  • ‘Watchful waiting’ – timely monitoring and review
  • Antibiotics and other medical treatments
  • Ear surgery (for example, myringotomy and myringoplasty) 
  • Wax removal and ear cleaning
  • GPs
  • Nurses
  • Audiologists
  • ENT specialists
  • Paediatricians
  • Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services
  • Other Indigenous-specific primary health-care services
  • Community clinics and health centres
  • Private practices and clinics
  • Hospitals
  • Outreach services 
  • Antibiotics can be provided by any medical practitioner
  • Surgery requires referral to ENT specialists and access to a hospital with trained surgical staff
Rehabilitation
  • Hearing aids, cochlear implants
  • Assistive listening devices
  • Communication training
  • Vestibular (balance) rehabilitation
  • Counselling
  • Education and support services
  • Early childhood development/ intervention services 
  • Speech therapy
  • Occupational therapy
  • Audiologists
  • Audiometrists
  • ENT specialists
  • GPs
  • Teachers of the deaf
  • Teachers and other educators
  • Support workers
  • Speech pathologists
  • Occupational therapists
  • Paediatricians
  • Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services
  • Other Indigenous-specific primary health-care services
  • Community clinics and health centres
  • Private practices and clinics
  • Hospital outpatient clinics
  • Outreach services in various settings
Referral required to access subsidised supports

Navigating ear and hearing health services

The ear and hearing health service system is extremely complex and navigating it can be challenging for patients and their families. The patient journey through the health system may require accessing numerous services from initial and follow-up screenings, diagnosis, medical interventions, through to rehabilitation services. Rehabilitation services include fitting of hearing aids or other hearing devices, early intervention services for children, speech pathology and occupational therapy. Educational, workplace and community supports may also be needed for patients to better communicate and to participate effectively at school, at work and in their community.

Multiple services and sectors are not typically joined up, and there are different challenges involved in accessing each of these services. This means it is difficult to navigate pathways through these services. This imposes a substantial burden on patients and their families, who need to advocate strongly to ensure the patient gets access to the right services at the right time.

There are critical points in the patient journey where delays in receiving care, and barriers to accessing care, may result in patients ‘falling out’ along the care pathway. As a result it can take substantial time to receive screening, diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation services such as referrals, ear nose and throat specialist consultations and surgery (Hearing Australia 2021).

An example of the complexity of the patient journey for children and young people as they move through the Queensland Government’s Deadly Ears Program is presented below (Figure INTRODUCTION 1). The program aims to enhance coordination across health, early childhood development and education sectors.

Figure INTRODUCTION 1: Patient journey through the Deadly Ears Program


Hearing Australia 2021. Urban hearing pathways: the role of accessibility and availability of hearing and ear health services in avoidable hearing loss for urban Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, report to the Australian Government Department of Health, Hearing Australia, accessed 10 September 2024.